Skip to main content

Is it possible to make objective decisions?

Do you think you make objective decisions?   Most people are adamant that they do, but I am becoming more and more aware of the influences that move me in particular directions, and am working to be more structured in approaching final decisions.

It constantly amazes me how many people honestly believe that any decision is better than none, and that changing your mind is a sign of indecisiveness and weakness.   Frequently, decisions are made based on the current information at hand, and when more becomes available, people believe it is too late to change direction.   Sometimes it is, lets face it, once a rocket has launched, new information can't bring it back, but there are many, many times when a decision is manipulated by interested parties, and the final decision maker believes that he will look weak if he goes back on his word, in spite of knowing that an alternative might very well be a better option.

It is true, though, that slow decision making can hamper growth as well as cause huge frustration, as we are an impatient bunch when the decision isn't ours to make, nor to bear the responsibility for failure.

No easy solution, but I find my best decisions are made when I don't jump in or get pressured by the lobbyists.   One of the best things about working at +Accsys is how passionate everybody is about the client experience and the products.   It is also one of the more challenging aspects as we tend to get quite intense and want to solve problems instantly.

Objective decision making should be a daily business objective.

Not always attainable, but always top of mind.

Without getting too deep into the psychology side, reading about confirmation bias has made me work harder on my objectivity and try to recognise my prejudices and subjectivity when making decisions. These range from hiring employees, purchasing (or personal shopping, much as I would prefer to just buy without analysing my motives) to dealing with bad debt and sales negotiations.

The 4 Card Test

Peter Wason coined the term confirmation bias and developed the 4 Card Test which indicated that most people will select the information that confirms their belief rather than the information which could contradict it.   When making objective decisions it is therefore critical to look at the issue from all angles, and get input from people who might have a different set of values and decision making criteria.

A major blow to objectivity is that we believe that success breeds success, and failure therefore has to breed failure.   And we look to confirm this prejudice which can set people and projects up for failure before they even start.   However, when we study some of the world's most successful people, they have risen from failure over and over.  Abraham Lincoln is a great case study for this.

Of course, we have to learn from history, and we need to address reasons for failure, but we should never assume the continuity of failure.   We often learn more from the things that go wrong than from the things that go right.   However, when making decisions, we regularly assume that if something went right, the underlying processes must have been correct.   Confirmation bias has kicked in, that's what we want to believe.

Objective decisions require a calm, cool, analytical approach and should include:

  • Gathering as much information as is possible
  • Analysing the information
  • Confirming whether any of the decision makers have skin in the game ie will they benefit personally from the decision?
  • Weighing up the alternative options
  • Selecting a path and then
  • Communicating the decision and the reasons behind it, so that all the stakeholders are on board.
  • Developing a contingency plan if the decision turns out to be less than ideal.
If possible, there should always be a Plan B, not to be a fence sitter, but for deeply practical reasons.



“I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work.”
Thomas A. Edison



Popular posts from this blog

Salespeople - Just Answer the Question.

How we love to elaborate…     Both in our personal and business lives.   It is rare to find somebody who simply answers the question.
In sales, it is becoming more and more critical to just say yes or no.   If you want to embroider afterwards, by all means, but tell the client you can or you can’t do it, first.

That’s what they remember, the yes or the no. Being married to an engineer, I have learnt that if I don’t answer the question, he simply repeats it, until he gets a definitive answer..
As the above is extremely bad for marital relationships, I try to say yes or no first and then give the details.

I thought it was just me, but I have been observing my friends and the people I work with, and it is fascinating how few one word answers are immediately available. When you are selling and a client asks you:
If the widget turns blue in the dark, say yes if it does, then ask if that is a key part of the decision making processIf they ask when you can deliver, give them a…

Hi, 22 year old me..

If I were 22 May is my birthday month, so a time for celebrations and introspection. In interviews, I often ask our applicants to pretend they are 60, and look back on their careers.   Their dreams range from leaving a legacy to being able to retire by the age of 45. At 22, I had taken my first steps on the career ladder.   I had been promoted from being a PA and Installation Secretary (setting up PoS installations for NCR’s large retailers) to becoming a full time programmer. I had made some extremely poor academic decisions, and realised I had to make some very good career choices.   Software development was a relatively new field when I was in my early 20s, and it became an exciting and fulfilling career. Based on my history what advice would I give myself or a new graduate? It doesn’t matter what you have studied, or what your first job is. Keep looking for your passion, find what makes you happy. If it’s money, and you don’t mind being a little unchallenged, as long as there is eno…

3 things to do BEFORE you resign

or sign a new contract…
1.Confirm your notice period ·A lot of companies allow 30 days from date of resignation, but many ask for a calendar month
2.Check your restraints ·If you are joining a competitor ·If you are joining a client
3.Find out when your last payment will be transferred ·Companies have been burned by paying over on the 25th, and people not returning, so they may delay payment transfer until the last official working day, or even the first day of the following month.  You may need to make special arrangements regarding debit orders ….
Both your current company and your new one deserve to be fairly treated.   Knowledge of the policies makes this possible.
Even if the policies don’t make sense to you, you agreed to them when you signed your contract.
HR managers will tell you how many great working relationships are damaged because people don’t follow policy when resigning. It’s worth taking the time for many good reasons.  Building a solid career can depend just as much on how you …